Your Big ROI Number Is Lying, and the Smart People Already Know It
Why most CRM attribution does not survive contact with a skeptic, and how to stop getting caught.
Let me save you a bad afternoon. Somewhere in your next deck is a number you love. It is big, it is round, and it wears a decimal point like a lab coat. And the sharpest person in the room is already loading the question that turns it to dust. I have been that person. I have also been the one holding the dust. The second one is worse, and it is avoidable.
Here is what nobody says out loud: a giant ROI number does not land as impressive with the people who matter. It lands as suspicious. The shinier it is, the faster a good operator assumes there is a denominator hiding under the rug. You wanted applause. You tripped the fraud detector.
Four tells that give you away
It is too big to be true. It is precise to a decimal in a world that does not measure that finely. It has no base, so your impressive multiple might be three sales dressed up as a movement. And it takes credit for revenue that was always going to happen. Stack all four and you have not made a case, you have handed the room permission to doubt everything else on the slide.
What the people who never get caught do
They make the method the hero and let the number ride shotgun. They run a holdout, because a control group is the difference between a story and a measurement. They match the verb to the evidence, drove when there is a control, contributed to when there is not, and yes, people notice. And they put the big number in finance's mouth, not their own, because a witness beats a brag every single time.
The move that feels insane and works
Say the number's weakness before anyone asks. Hand them the smaller, cleaner figure first, the one you would actually bet your reputation on. It feels like giving up ground. It is the professional version of showing your work in pen. People trust the person who already knows where the bodies are buried, because that person clearly is not afraid of the dig.
I am not anti-ambition. I will lean into the hubris all day. Just bring receipts that survive a hostile read, because someone in that room read the same playbook you did, and they are not clapping yet.
Anthony
← More writing · If this was useful, or wrong in an interesting way, tell me: hireme@crmjedi.com.
Get the next one by email
New essays on customer data, measurement, and what actually ships. No spam, no cadence theater.